Antidotal info on JavaScript Library Ext JS

I’m in conversation with a group that’s using Ext JS for their RIA. As I haven’t used it, I thought I’d go ask at the international water fountain that is twitter about it.

Anyone using Ext JS? Thoughts compared to jQuery or Prototype/Scriptaculous?about 3 hours ago from TweetDeck

 

This is what I got back (I love twitter):

Kevin Hoytparkerkrhoyt@joshholmes IMHO, Ext is more about traditional applications. jQuery is a Swiss Army knife. Ext can do that, but rarely is used that way.about 1 hour ago from TwitterFon in reply to joshholmes

Nate Schuttantschutta@joshholmes friend of mine loves ext but the learning curve can be steep and leads to lots of js config rather then HTML. I like proto a tonabout 2 hours ago from twitterrific in reply to joshholmes

Joe O'Brienobjo@joshholmes we have tried all three and much prefer jquery. but ext is in a very different space with diff objectivesabout 2 hours ago from Nambu in reply to joshholmes

Kevin Marshallksmarshall@joshholmes I use extjs and jquery together. I just use extjs for some of the nice ui controls it creates and jquery for the rest of the jsabout 2 hours ago from twitterrific

Dave Meekerdmeeker@joshholmes We’ve looked at it extensively. It seems to be a mishmosh of those other libraries, no? I can put you in touch with someone hereabout 3 hours ago from web in reply to joshholmes

Jeff Blankenburgjblankenburg@joshholmes My limited experience suggests it’s much more a RIA development framework than jquery, etc.about 3 hours ago from TweetDeck in reply to joshholmes

Nate Koharinkohari@joshholmes ExtJS is nice if you’re looking for a full control toolkit. If you just want a low-level JS library, jQuery is the best imo.about 3 hours ago from TweetDeck in reply to joshholmes

Trackback Permanent Link

A comment to "Antidotal info on JavaScript Library Ext JS"

  1. Iulian wrote:

    ExtJS is perfect for RIA. Compared to jQuery, ExtJS has a lot of components like trees, grids ready to use with just a few lines of code.
    jQuery fits better for websites that don’t need that much of RIA style.

    Indeed, ExtJS’ learning curve can be steep, but once you get at the top evertything about Ext seems to be so normal. ExtJS implies a very good understanding of *object inheritance* in JS.

Leave a comment

Creative Commons License
Josh Holmes's Blog by Josh Holmes is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
Based on a work at joshholmes.com.